Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Anu MacIntosh-Murray🇨🇦's avatar

Shankar, I can appreciate the argument, but it breaks my heart that our prospects depend on fossil fuel expansion which damages the environment. How I wish we could get away from that dependence and shift the equation to renewables.

Tracy*numquam cede's avatar

Thank you Shankar for your insight.

Our PM is a pragmatist. Imagine the philosophical internal debates he must have had with himself being a net zero guy, environmentalist (as I am) and move hard on fossil fuels like oil and gas, and LNG. The difference is that ours are one of the cleanest in the world. This matters.

India needs heavy energy as it further industrializes away from dirty coal. Other countries as well. We cannot prevent the rest of the world from using fossil fuels, so the next best thing is to use our strongest resource assets, as responsibly as we can, and provide that energy to those emerging economies. We grow our economy away from the USA, gain strength, and also in parallel grow our clean energy transition where possible, so that we can also be a global leader on clean energy initiatives and solutions. In short, we provide both solutions when an emerging country is ready for them. Nuclear, like the CANDU reactors is another way, for like-minded allies.

There is no perfect answer, this is existential for Canada to survive. From that place we can do the important work we need to do as a global leader for democratic values, clean technology, and other important work. We cannot do that work if we do not survive. Hard choices, but necessary.

29 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?